Economic Impact Report
Yanbu Industrial City — Phase Initial · Registry: registry-yanbu-v1
Three modules. One corridor. The same 300 TPD Phase Initial deployment that addresses 105,000 tpy toward Saudi Arabia's MWAN 2035 mandate also initiates the Kingdom's largest single-site V₂O₅ recovery from YASREF petcoke ash and the first industrial-scale circular polymer-to-advanced-materials manufacturing — at zero Authority capital, generating net surplus from Year 2 onward.
Decision Summary
| Parameter | State A — Current System | State B — Option A (ACM, 3 modules) |
|---|---|---|
| Annual disposal cost | Ongoing — petcoke + polymer streams may carry hazardous premium WARN-01 | Processing Service (Ijarah) — Year 1 only net outflow |
| Capital obligation | Ongoing disposal spend (no asset created) | Zero LOCKED |
| Year 2+ net | Disposal cost escalating — 3× Jubail volume | Net surplus — Revenue Share exceeds Processing Service on 105,000 tpy |
| V₂O₅ / critical minerals | None — YASREF petcoke ash landfilled | V₂O₅ from YASREF/SAMREF → Aramco VRFB supply chain WARN-01 for vanadium conc. |
| Polymer waste | YANSAB polymer rejects — no circular processor | RC3/RC4 carbon materials → SABIC off-take (CANDIDATE) |
| MWAN contribution | None | 105,000 tpy toward 2035 mandate ESTIMATED |
| Employment | No new in-Kingdom FTE | 141 direct FTE + 423 indirect ESTIMATED — Nitaqat-labeled |
- Compresses MWAN compliance contribution by 12 months — at 3× Jubail volume, the mandate impact is proportionally greater
- Delays Saudi Arabia's V₂O₅ supply from the largest national refinery complex by 12 months
- Delays polymer waste circular manufacturing — YANSAB continues with disposal at escalating cost
State A — Current System Baseline
- Industrial waste streams (MSW, sludge, recycling, C&D): SAR 140–200/ton ESTIMATED
- Petcoke/refinery ash (YASREF/SAMREF): SAR 180–280/ton — potential hazardous premium above standard rate WARN-01
- Polymer waste (YANSAB): SAR 150–250/ton — no incumbent circular processor; disposal only
- Blended FWDC: SAR 290/ton · $77.33/ton ESTIMATED ⚠ WARN-01
State A structural position: 400 TPD (140,000 tpy) of industrial waste generating no manufactured output, no critical minerals, no MWAN diversion credit. YASREF petcoke vanadium continues landfilled. YANSAB polymer waste continues as disposal cost with no circular value recovery.
State B — Deployment Baseline
| Volume | 105,000 tpy (300 TPD × 350 days) — 3 modules LOCKED |
|---|---|
| T0 | Q2 2027 ESTIMATED |
| COD | Q4 2029 ESTIMATED |
| Revenue Share lag | 13 months rolling — independent transaction ALWAYS |
| Carbotura FDI | $165M (SAR 618.75M) (3 modules × $55M) LOCKED |
Delta Analysis
Year 1: Processing Service paid. Zero Revenue Share. Pre-royalty 13-month period. Net: outflow only. Month 14+: Revenue Share commences rolling monthly on all 3 modules. Independent transaction. Year 2+: Revenue Share exceeds Processing Service on full 105,000 tpy volume — net surplus.
System-Level Impact
Employment ESTIMATED — Nitaqat-labeled
| Category | Phase Initial (3 modules) |
|---|---|
| Direct FTE (in-Kingdom) | 141 |
| Indirect | 423 |
| National Content (IKTVA proxy) | 62% ESTIMATED |
Subject to Nitaqat compliance. In-Kingdom composition confirmed at Feasibility Study with HRSD (WARN-03).
Environmental Delta
| Metric | State A | State B — Phase Initial |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon avoidance | 0 | 399,675 tCO₂e/yr ESTIMATED |
| SGI contribution | None | 399,675 tCO₂e/yr toward 278M tCO₂e target |
| MWAN compliance | None | 105,000 tpy toward 2035 mandate |
| Polymer waste circular recovery | None — disposal only | 80 TPD YANSAB polymer → RC3/RC4 output |
| V₂O₅ recovery | None — landfilled | YASREF/SAMREF petcoke → V₂O₅ for VRFB chain |
Risk and Sensitivity
| # | Risk | Mitigation |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Petcoke ash hazardous classification — higher FWDC | Net surplus is independent of FWDC. Higher disposal cost strengthens State A cost argument. |
| 2 | V₂O₅ concentration below commercial threshold | YASREF heavy crude is known high-vanadium source — lower risk than generic petcoke. Engineering confirmation required WARN-01 |
| 3 | YANSAB polymer waste access — SABIC gate | YANSAB (SABIC 51%) and SIRC (PIF) engagement at authority level. SABIC is also off-take CANDIDATE. |
| 4 | Nitaqat compliance for 141 FTE | Feasibility Study with HRSD — WARN-03 |
| 5 | SAR/USD currency | Pegged at 3.75 — minimal risk VERIFIED |